Full Supplemental Draft results
| Pick | Team | Player | Position |
| 1 | Charlotte | Garrett Thul | Attack |
| 2 | Florida | Cameron Lao-Gosney | Midfield |
| 3 | Ohio (From Chesapeake) | Ty Souders | Defense |
| 4 | Boston | Josh Amidon | Midfield |
| 5 | Ohio | Steven Boyle | Attack |
| 6 | New York | Shamel Bratton | Midfield |
| 7 | Rochester | Jeremy Boltus | Attack |
| 8 | Denver | Tim Henderson | Defense |
| 9 | Charlotte | Michael Italiano | Defense |
| 10 | Florida | Sam Snow | Midfield |
| 11 | Chesapeake | Matt Striebel | Midfield |
| 12 | Boston | David Emala | Attack |
| 13 | Ohio | Martin Cahill | Midfield |
| 14 | New York | Shane Sturgis | Attack |
| 15 | Rochester | Rob Guida | Midfield |
| 16 | Denver | Andrew Combs | Attack |
| 17 | Charlotte | Billy Ward | Midfield |
| 18 | Florida | Zack Losco | Midfield |
| 19 | Chesapeake | Chris Hipps | Defense |
| 20 | New York (From Boston) | Stephen Peyser | Midfield |
| 21 | Ohio | Zach Palmer | Attack |
| 22 | New York | Lee Coppersmith | Midfield |
| 23 | Rochester | Steven Dircks | Defense |
| 24 | Denver | Pat Harbeson | Midfield |
| 25 | Charlotte | Jack Runkel | Goalie |
| 26 | Denver (From Florida) | Johnny Rodriguez | Goalie |
| 27 | Denver (From Florida, from Chesapeake) | Matt Harris | Defense |
| 28 | Boston | Ricky Pages | Defense |
| 29 | Ohio | Roger Ferguson | Defense |
| 30 | Charlotte (From New York) | Alex Zomerfeld | Midfield |
| 31 | Rochester | Ryan Feuerstein | Midfield |
| 32 | Denver | Ethan Vedder | Midfield |
| 33 | Charlotte | John Fennessy | Defense |
| 34 | Florida | Mario Ventiquattro | Attack |
| 35 | Chesapeake | Andrew Scalley | Attack |
| 36 | Boston | Andrew Sellers | Defense |
| 37 | Ohio | Trevor Timmerberg | Midfield |
| 38 | New York | Cody Jamieson | Attack |
| 39 | Rochester | Beau Wood | Attack |
| 40 | Denver | Jeff Froccaro | Attack |
| 41 | Charlotte | Sean Meagher | Defense |
| 42 | Florida | Pat Kiernan | Defense |
| 43 | Chesapeake | Chris Conroy | Defense |
| 44 | Boston | Brett Garber | Midfield |
| 45 | Ohio | RG Keenan | Midfield |
| 46 | New York | Chris Picirilli | Defense |
| 47 | Rochester | Mike O’Neil | Midfield |
| 48 | Denver | Luke Cometti | Midfield |
| 49 | Charlotte | Glenn Maiorano | Defense |
| 50 | Florida | Will Mangan | Midfield |
| 51 | Chesapeake | Dean Gibbons | Attack |
| 52 | Boston | Matt White | Attack |
| 53 | Ohio | Stefan Schroder | Goalie |
| 54 | New York | Anthony Biscardi | Midfield |
| 55 | Rochester | Adam Rand | Midfield |
| 56 | Denver | Matthew Callahan | Defense |
| 57 | Charlotte | Casey Cittadino | Defense |
| 58 | Florida | Tom Croonquist | FO |
| 59 | Chesapeake | Matt Lovejoy | Defense |
| 60 | Boston | Jack Murphy | Goalie |
| 61 | Ohio | James Delaney | Midfield |
| 62 | Chesapeake (From New York) | Sam Bradman | Midfield |
| 63 | Rochester | Jason Lashomb | Goalie |
| 64 | Denver | Greg Downing | Midfield |
| 65 | Charlotte | Riley Loewen | Attack |
| 66 | Florida | Mike McCormack | Defense |
| 67 | Chesapeake | Joe Lisicky | Defense |
| 68 | Boston | Matt Messina | Midfield |
| 69 | Ohio | Derek Muzio | Defense |
| 70 | New York | Matt Poskay | Midfield |
| 71 | Rochester | Steve Murphy | Midfield |
| 72 | Denver | Corey Elmer | Attack |
| 73 | Charlotte | Todd Nakasuji | Attack |
| 74 | Florida | Tim Desko | Attack |
| 75 | Chesapeake | Ben McIntosh | Midfield |
| 76 | Boston | Eric Lusby | Attack |
| 77 | Ohio | Andrew Barton | Midfield |
| 78 | New York | Andrew Casimir | Defense |
| 79 | Rochester | Anthony Starnino | Defense |
| 80 | Denver | Brian Feeney | Goalie |
| 81 | Charlotte | Nico Capron | Defense |
| 82 | Florida | Nick O’Hara | Defense |
| 83 | Chesapeake | Jovan Miller | Midfield |
| 84 | Boston | Ryan Hollenbaugh | Defense |
| 85 | Ohio | Tom LaCrosse | Midfield |
| 86 | New York | Matt Van Bourgondien | Midfield |
| 87 | Rochester | Thomas Freshour | Defense |
| 88 | Denver | Aaron Prosser | Midfield |
| 89 | Charlotte | Will Blakely | Attack |
| 90 | Florida | Bryce Dabbs | Midfield |
| 91 | Chesapeake | Dylan Levings | Midfield |
| 92 | Boston | Matt Dolente | Midfield |
| 93 | Ohio | Carter Bender | Midfield |
| 94 | New York | Rhamel Bratton | Midfield |
| 95 | Rochester | Brian Schultz | Attack |
| 96 | Denver | Ryan Licht | Defense |
Teams whose roster was less than 35 players were allowed an additional selection as follows
Florida Chazz Woodson Attack
Chesapeake Peter Schwartz Midfield
Boston Eric Hagarty Goalie
New York Chris Coppolecchia Defense
