We’ve seen a lot of surprises happen this season in college lacrosse, from the emergence of new faces and new teams, to players such as Bryant’s Gunnar Waldt fall almost out of existence. Here are my All-American selections at this point in the season, which have 4 attackmen, 4 middies, a FOGO, an LSM, 4 defensemen, and a goalie:
First Team
| A | Lyle Thompson | Senior | Albany |
| A | Dylan Molloy | Sophomore | Brown |
| A | Dylan Donahue | Redshirt Junior | Syracuse |
| A | Jimmy Bitter | Senior | North Carolina |
| M | Myles Jones | Junior | Duke |
| M | Connor Buczek | Senior | Cornell |
| M | Greg Coholan | Junior | Virginia |
| M | Jesse King | Senior | Ohio State |
| FOGO | Trevor Baptiste | Freshman | Denver |
| LSM | Larken Kemp | Sophomore | Brown |
| D | Matt Landis | Junior | Notre Dame |
| D | Casey Ikeda | Senior | Maryland |
| D | Brandon Mullins | Redshirt Junior | Syracuse |
| D | Chris Fennell | Sophomore | Navy |
| G | Kyle Bernlohr | Redshirt Junior | Maryland |
Second Team
| A | Matt Kavanagh | Junior | Notre Dame |
| A | Kevin Rice | Senior | Syracuse |
| A | Mike MacDonald | Senior | Princeton |
| A | Joey Sankey | Senior | North Carolina |
| M | Deemer Class | Junior | Duke |
| M | Ryan Tucker | Senior | Virginia |
| M | Kip Orban | Senior | Princeton |
| M | Ryan Belka | Senior | Drexel |
| FOGO | Ben Williams | Sophomore | Syracuse |
| LSM | Peter MacCartney | Senior | Syracuse |
| D | JoJo Ostrander | Senior | Towson |
| D | Christian Burgdorf | Sophomore | Denver |
| D | Austin Pifani | Sophomore | North Carolina |
| D | Austin Schultz | Junior | Army |
| G | Shane Doss | Sophomore | Notre Dame |
Granted, there’s still plenty of season left to play. And I think none of these spots are locked in, even Lyle Thompson’s. This is the point of the season where All-Americans are seen and whether or not they can help change the outcome of a game.
